Policy and Procedures for the Administration of Unrelated Business Income Tax
Policy and Procedures for the Administration of Unrelated Business Income Tax
Background Information
Background Information
Unrelated business income is defined as gross income derived by an exempt organization from any unrelated trade or business that is regularly carried on:
- Trade or Business
- Regularly Carried On
- Not Substantially Related to Exempt Purpose
If an activity is undertaken with the intent to create a profit through the sale of goods or the performance of a service it is considered a trade or business. The determination of whether an activity constitutes a trade or business depends on the facts and circumstances of each situation, however certain factors may indicate whether such a motive exists including active solicitation of clientele, charging at rates above cost, and openly competing with other commercial enterprises.
An activity is regularly carried on unless it is performed infrequent or discontinuously. In determining whether intermittently conducted activities are regularly carried on, the manner of the activity must be compared with the manner in which similar commercial activities are performed. For example, where an exempt organization sells greeting cards for only a few weeks during the holiday season, this activity would be considered “regularly carried on” if it is expected to routinely occur each holiday season.
An activity is not substantially related when it does not contribute to the exempt purpose of the organization. For example, tuition revenue clearly contributes to the exempt purpose of a university as it is the revenue collected for the educational service a university provides. Revenue generated from operating a grocery store that sells merchandise to the general public, however, would likely not be substantially related to a university’s exempt purpose.
The activities of the University of Massachusetts (the University) that are exempt from federal income tax are research and discovery, teaching and learning, outreach and public service. These exempt purposes constitute most of the University's activities. Any revenue generating University activity not substantially related to these activities is categorized as unrelated to the exempt purpose, and may be subject to federal unrelated business income tax (UBIT).
Categorizing the numerous operations of the campus to these broad descriptions can be very difficult. The importance of doing so has income tax ramifications since the University is tax exempt for related activities and taxable at federal levels for business activities that are not substantially related to the tax-exempt purpose. Income and expense information for unrelated business activities included on the University’s UBIT return must be reported to the University Tax Management Office (the Tax Office) on an annual basis. Form 990-T is the income tax return filed by exempt organizations to report unrelated business income (UBI).
Policy Statement
Policy Statement
It is the policy of the University to comply with Internal Revenue Service (IRS) regulations, which includes filing IRS Form 990-T for Unrelated Business Income Taxes (UBIT). Therefore, all unrelated business income and expenses carried on by the University will be properly distributed and recorded in the revenue and expense accounts assigned to the unrelated business activity to determine federal UBIT. This must be completed in accordance with the annual tax calendar.
Scope
Scope
This policy applies to the income and expenses of unrelated business activities conducted by the University campuses: Amherst, Boston, Dartmouth, Lowell, Medical School including Commonwealth Medicine and MassBiologics, the System Office and UMass Online as well as shared services. It also applies to campus entities which are separately incorporated or exempt under Section 501(c) of the Internal Revenue Code (Code). Examples of such entities include:
- Worcester City Corporation;
- Foundations;
- Alumni associations; and
- Faculty clubs.
However, these entities are responsible for filing their own annual information and income tax returns with the IRS.
This policy does not apply to the University of Massachusetts Building Authority.
Responsibilities
Responsibilities
Program managers and/or department heads of proposed and existing campus activities shall review their particular operations for possible exposure to UBIT. Passive income sources such as dividends, interest, annuities, royalties, real property rent, do not represent a trade or business activity and are generally exempt. Operations should not be terminated simply to avoid paying taxes. These programs must have proper pricing structures to allow for the cost of operations and the additional tax burdens.
Each activity generating unrelated business income must be able to document all revenues as well as all expenses incurred in creating those revenues. The expenses must include both the expenditures directly charged to the business activity as well as expenditures that may be included in overhead.
Summary of Department responsibilities:
- As new revenue streams arise, consult with the Campus Controller’s Office to determine if the new activity is subject to UBIT.
- Track revenue and expenses for activities identified as subject to UBIT.
- Communicate with Campus Controller as to tax accrual process if needed. Each campus will determine a date that the departments must submit revenue and expense items for UBI activities to the Campus Controller.
- Ensure that detailed records are maintained that segregate the department's unrelated and related income.
- The Tax Office will include a profit motive questionnaire in the UBIT package (see Controller’s responsibilities #4 for definition of UBIT package), which will be distributed to applicable departments. Each department is responsible for completing the documents included in the UBIT package including the profit motive questionnaire and providing a business plan for any activity that has shown losses for three or more years. The completed documents must be returned to the Campus Controller in accordance with the annual calendar.
- Along with the Campus Controller’s Office, ensure that costs associated with teaching, research, or other exempt activities of the department are not allocated to the unrelated activities.
Summary of Campus Controller’s Office responsibilities:
- Campus Controllers are responsible for oversight and review of the UBIT activities.
- Work with the departments and/or the Tax Office to identify reasonable good faith, separation of activities using IRS NAICS guidance. A tax exempt organization with more than one trade of business must calculate UBIT separately with respect to each unrelated trade or business. This is called “siloing”. With respect to siloing, the IRS provides for us to rely on the North American Industry Classification System (NAICS) 2-digit codes for purposes of identifying separate trades or businesses.
- Consult with departments and advise as to UBIT applicability throughout year.
- Provide applicable departments with UBIT package by applicable date. The UBIT package consists of a standard reporting package that includes a profit motive questionnaire, a UBIT checklist of activities, and a summary of each activities revenues and expenses.
- Review revenue and expense accounts to ensure proper distribution between the department's exempt functions and unrelated functions.
- Along with the departments ensure that costs associated with teaching, research, or other exempt activities of the department are not allocated to the unrelated activities.
- Review cost allocation structure with the Tax Office to ensure it is reasonable.
- Provide completed UBIT package to the Tax Office in accordance with the annual calendar.
- Provide the Tax Office with quarterly estimates of UBI tax payments based on agreed upon annual calendar.
- Accrue for UBIT tax as applicable. Communicate to the departments that they may have a tax liability.
- Both the Controllers and Tax Office are responsible for training the departments.
Summary of the Tax Office responsibilities:
- Prepare quarterly estimates tax calendar and provide to Controllers in accordance with the annual calendar.
- Work with Controllers and departments to develop, coordinate, and lead campus UBI tax training.
- Notify campuses of due dates for quarterly estimates, and prepare and pay quarterly estimates.
- Send UBIT packages to Controllers in accordance with the annual calendar.
- Aggregate activities across campuses by NAICS codes or other reasonable, good faith effort.
- Assist Controllers with determining the tax status of each new activity with a potential for generating unrelated business income, based on the UBIT checklist completed annually by the campus.
- File applicable Form 990-T tax extensions with IRS in accordance with the annual calendar.
- Analyze information gathered from campuses, financial statements, and other books & records and develop questions for Controllers in accordance with the annual calendar.
- Aggregate data and file Form 990-T in accordance with the annual calendar.
- Provide campuses with annual inter-campus allocation analysis of UBIT tax owed/paid to IRS. Facilitate payment and settlement of UBIT tax between the campuses.
- Manage correspondence with tax agencies and tax firms as needed.
- Issue tax guidelines to assist campuses in understanding and complying with UBI tax law.
Procedures
Procedures
Annually, the Tax Office will distribute the UBIT package to the Controllers of each campus. The Controllers will distribute the package to each department/division to review and complete. The Controllers are responsible for reviewing, approving and submitting each department’s UBIT packages to the Tax Office. This review allows the Campus Controller to verify that (s)he is aware of the unrelated activities that are being performed on their campus. It also provides proper notification to the Controller of any new activities, and provides information for activities that may need further investigation.
The Tax Office will offer guidance in interpreting the laws regarding taxability of an activity and assist in determining whether any exceptions to UBIT may apply.
Additionally, the Tax Office will prepare and file all applicable tax returns with the IRS and state/local taxing authorities as well as manage any correspondence with these agencies. Any liability resulting from UBIT will be charged to the applicable campus.
Details
The Campus Controllers are responsible for oversight and review of their Campus revenue-generating activities and for coordination with the Tax Office to determine reportable UBIT activities.
Certain University activities may generate both related and unrelated income; as such, the Controllers and the Tax Office should meet, as needed, with departments. Additionally, University contracts and or agreements should be reviewed to determine the nature of the activity that is generating the
revenue. To document for the IRS that the University has made a good faith effort to identify unrelated activity, Controllers:
Provide a memo listing what activities were looked at, who was contacted, what was concluded, and why; and
Include in this memo an affirmation that campus research activities have been reviewed as well as the conclusion of what income can be excluded under the “research exception” versus what income is subject to UBIT.
- Contact the Tax Office on questionable activities.
Cost Allocations
Expenses used to offset unrelated revenues must have a “proximate and primary” relationship to the unrelated revenues. Expenses incurred to generate non-taxable income cannot be used as deductions to reduce taxable income. Cost allocation methodologies should be defensible, consistent and reasonable. The IRS can disallow expenses based on improper allocations between related and unrelated income-producing activities. Controllers are responsible for maintaining the permanent records associated with cost allocations and for documenting the methodologies.
Further, the IRS has stated that the unadjusted gross-to-gross method (using a ratio of gross income from an unrelated trade or business activity over the total gross income from both related and unrelated activities generating the same indirect expenditures to allocate expenses between them) is not reasonable either under the general allocation rule or for purposes of IRC Section 512(a)(6).
Preparing and Retaining Documentation
In case of an IRS challenge, Campus Controllers, departments and the Tax Office will be required to substantiate the elements of revenue and expense; defend cost allocation methods; and explain why activities were, or were not, reported on the UBIT return.
Unrelated Activities That Result in Losses
Unrelated losses from an activity can be used to offset future unrelated gains from that activity only when the activity was conducted with the intent to profit when the loss was generated. For example, this can occur when a new unrelated trade or business is incurring significant startup costs in the initial years, or when an ongoing one incurs a significant loss of revenue for a year.
- Profit motive questionnaires. To document whether or not a profit motive exists, a profit motive questionnaire must be submitted to the Tax Office for each unrelated activity that results in a loss. Also, other documentation that will help to substantiate business purpose and profit motive, such as minutes, business plans, etc., should be retained.
- Documenting the loss. For loss activities conducted with a profit motive, UBIT Packages must be submitted to the Tax Office. For loss activities conducted without a profit motive, the Controllers must retain documentation sufficient to prove to the IRS that a loss resulted. If a UBIT Package is submitted, the summary sheet should include a statement that the activity was conducted without the intent to profit the University financially. This loss will not be included in the 990-T.
Common Examples & Exceptions
Common Examples & Exceptions
Common Examples of Activities Subject to UBIT
The laws regarding UBIT are complex and determining when an activity is subject to tax is highly dependent upon the facts and circumstances of each situation. However, below is a list of activities that usually trigger UBIT concerns in a college or university setting. This list is not exhaustive:
- Advertising, such as that contained in University publications, on billboards, scoreboards, radio and television shows or in other printed materials distributed at University events;
- Corporate sponsorships that impart a substantial return benefit upon the part of the sponsor;
- Rental income from the use of equipment or other tangible personal property;
- Rental of parking lot spaces to the general public;
- Rental of dorm space to non-students;
- Certain forms of research or product testing conducted for commercial businesses;
- Entertainment events;
- Merchandising services;
- Travel tours;
- Sports camps;
- Catering or event planning services conducted for members of the general public;
- Qualified transportation fringe benefits.
Exceptions to UBIT
Exceptions to UBIT are likewise complex and too numerous to list. A list of exceptions that most frequently apply is provided below:
- Dividends, interest, capital gains and similar portfolio income;
- Royalties, unless the agreement calls for substantial services to be provided by the organization such as management services;
- Scientific research conducted for government;
- Business operated for the convenience of students or employees, such as student laundry services, parking revenue received from students or employees, or the sale of supplies to students or employees;
- Certain qualified sponsorships, if properly structured;
- Work performed substantially by volunteers;
- Sale of merchandise which was received by the University as a gift or contribution;
- Meetings, conferences and seminars where education or training is provided by the University;
- Entertainment events that include music and drama for students, faculty, and the general public.